Is this a result of a senior moment? Because I've read this book before! I read it in 2018. And I reviewed it in 2018! And this is what I wrote.
The story introduces the character of Cate Austin who features in subsequent novels of Ms. Dugdall. Cate is a probation officer who has to decide whether Rose Wilks convicted of child manslaughter should be considered for parole based on whether she is remorseful for the death of the child. I veer away from anything that might resemble a spoiler so I’ll say no more than that.
But what I will say is that this is an very well plotted story giving us parallel accounts; Cate’s is in familiar third person narrative and Rose’s true account is given in a first person narrative and in the form of her ‘Black Book’ entries written for her partner, Jason, and allows the reader to witness with Rose the unfurling of what actually happened. It’s very much a ‘did she, didn’t she’, ‘will she,wont she’ type story but when that is well done it is delicious to read. And it’s well done here with a twist at the end which I found curiously subliminal in that I half suspected it but ultimately rejected it.
The specific prison locations and protocols were authentic and believable, well researched but then I find that Ms. Dugdall was herself a probation officer. What was that they used to tell us in school? Write about what you know. Well, here is the perfect example and the more believable for it.
It’s dark and disturbing but keeps the reader gripped throughout. I didn’t find any of the characters especially engaging or likeable, especially Rose but I’m not sure I was supposed to. I think it was necessary to remain dispassionate almost. But paradoxically there is a lot of emotion in the book especially for mothers and an all embracing sadness that speaks of things that should have been avoidable but never were, wrong places, wrong times, recipes for disaster.
It’s an easy read, undemanding in terms of a well paced, flowing narrative and a most pleasant way to while way a few hours. So if you’re finding yourself snowbound this week grab yourself a copy!!
Is it a copout to just reproduce something I've already written? Maybe. Can I add anything to what I've already written? We'll see. Nowadays rereading a book is something of a luxury because I just have so many unread books and there are so many new books coming out that I want to read I seldom get around to it. This was an opportunity to reread a book that I might not have chosen to reread. And I'm always curious as to whether my response changes. What is also interesting is the incarnations that this book has gone through. Because I believe it was originally published in 2006, published in 2018 and again now in 2026 with a different publisher. The author acknowledges this book's journey at the conclusion of the book. And recognises that some of the social and cultural changes in the world mean that there is a heightened understanding of importance of probation officers. So it's a smart move to republish the Cate Austin books. I think it raises interesting considerations about time and place. Perhaps this book is more relevant now than when it was first published? But I would stick by everything I said originally, the shifting climate of our times hasn't changed the essence of the book for me anyway. But twenty years since it was first published? Might you be forgiven to think that it could come across as dated? You might, but it doesn't. It feels very fresh and relevant. And I find it a curious coincidence that when I read and reviewed it before we were in the grips of snow and here we are again...... in the grips of snow!
My thanks to HQ stories for my 2026 copy.
